Skip to main content

VALLEY SHEPHERD CREAMERY

OUR CHEESE

From three streams of milk, sheep, goat and cow, we craft a growing list of cheeses. Many are old standards that our customers have grown to love and ask for again and again. Some are seasonal or experimental. Below are most of our regularly available cheeses. All made in small batches and then sent up to our aging cave. Enjoy them for what they are: A fleeting snapshot of a single dairy herd, grazing on one pasture, milked to fill one vat, allowing us to create a single batch.

NAME

Asbury

MILK TYPE

Goat and cow mix- Pasteurized

PRODUCTION

A mix of goat and rich Jersey cow milk is pasteurized and inoculated with lactic bacteria. The curd gel is cut, warmed and stirred. Lengthy cooking is typically needed on goat milk cheese due to low protein but when the curd is deemed ready by hand feel, the vat is emptied quickly into many small molds. The 2Lb wheels are pressed lightly overnight.

AFFINAGE

A mix of goat and rich Jersey cow milk is pasteurized and inoculated with lactic bacteria.  The curd gel is cut, warmed and stirred.  Lengthy cooking is typically needed on goat milk cheese due to low protein but when the curd is deemed ready by hand feel, the vat is emptied quickly into many small molds.  The 2Lb wheels are pressed lightly overnight.

TASTING NOTES

A very mild goat tang and a rich mouth feel of jersey cow milk combine to make this a new favorite.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Califon Tomme

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Borenkaas (Dutch country Gouda) production requiring a mid process hot water curd wash.Made from full rich, full fat Jersey cow milk. Ten pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days minimum aging on Ash wood slabs in cave room at 50-54f. Some wheels are allowed to go up to 180 days.

TASTING NOTES

Semi-hard, with a stick to the roof of your mouth, smooth texture and containing a few holes. Aged for several months, this cheese provides a rich nutty flavor that intensifies with fruity undertones over time.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Carameaway

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Gouda with Caraway added to the curd during processing and before final molding. Made from full fat Jersey cow milk. Ten pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days minimum aging on Ash wood slabs in cave room at 50-54f.

TASTING NOTES

Semi-hard, with a stick to the roof of your mouth, smooth texture and containing a few holes. The Caraway seed inclusion adds the typical herbal component that has made this cheese famous and has given it a name in the Netherlands: LydenKaas.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Crema De Blue

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Typical blue curd production for open curd texture requiring gentle hand stirring for 3 hours. Topless, bottomless molds over drainage matts for free whey run. Wheels are pierced for aeration on day 3. Three pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Sixty five days aging in cold cave room.  Aluminized wrap after thirty days to slow bluing and encourage pate development.

TASTING NOTES

Rich, spicy yet creamy blue cheese. Curd texture is almost spreadable and the blue-green veins add a sharp, spicy flavor that provides an excellent contrast to its richness.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Gottagetagoat

MILK TYPE

Goat - Raw

PRODUCTION

Raw goat milk incubated with simple lactic bacteria and renneted with veal rennet. The curd is cut into medium size particles and undergoes the traditional whey removal/ hot water replacement process (curd wash.) Typical goat milk is lower on protein and fat and hence yields a soft, white curd that requires longer heat/stir time. When ready, the curd is pressed into ten pound gouda molds.

AFFINAGE

Simple aging on Ash wood slabs. Three to five months in our main hard cheese aging room. Growing molds are brushed off regularly. Like many Gouda types, this cheese can age for much longer then its minimum and develop wonderful caramel notes.

TASTING NOTES

It has a pleasantly mild, fresh taste with a light goat tang and a creamy mouth feel.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Melter Skelter

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Raclette production.  The production involves a medium cut, hand mix and curd washed pate. Wheels are pressed into fairly thin large disks of twelve to fourteen pounds.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days in a special high humidity cave room. Rind is brine washed to light tackiness.

TASTING NOTES

Creamy texture and a salty, slightly sweet, slightly nutty flavor not unlike Gruyere. It’s fairly aromatic and becomes more pungent the longer the cheese wheel is aged.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

MoreBeer

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Medium temperature curd management, hand forming and molding. Washed curd texturing with a vegetable ash center line. Ten pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days aging on wood in high humidity.  Washed rind several times per week resulting in a tacky rind. Supple, semi soft interior.

TASTING NOTES

Mild taste and leaves a wonderful, nutty aftertaste. Complex and fruity  with a slight zing. The pâte is supple, springy, and silky when touched, yet dry and sticky at the same time. The vegetable ash separating the cheese makes a dramatic presentation and has a complex, bold flavor. Can be the centerpiece of any cheese plate, used on sandwiches and melts well.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Nettlesome

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Gouda with Nettles added to the curd during processing and before final molding. Made from full fat Jersey cow milk. Ten pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Traditional Gouda with Nettles added to the curd during processing and before final molding. Made from full fat Jersey cow milk. Ten pound wheel.

TASTING NOTES

Semi-hard, with a stick to the roof of your mouth, smooth texture and containing a few holes. The Nettles inclusion adds a vegetal, almost meaty component that has propelled Nettlesome to our top 5 over the last twenty years.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Oldwick Shepherd

MILK TYPE

Sheep - Raw

PRODUCTION

Our signature product is simple utilizing the properties of grass fed sheep milk. Due to the elevated protein levels in sheep’s milk, the milk turns to a curd in just twenty minutes. It is quickly cut into 1cm cubes and molded into 5 pound wheels.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days on Ash boards is enough to free the flavors and aromas locked in fresh sheep’s milk.

TASTING NOTES

Underneath its moldy, iron-gray rind hides an ivory-colored body that is somewhat granular and creamy in its texture and melts very easily. The flavors are rich and robust – reminiscent of nuts and toasted wheat, sweet and slightly grassy.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Pepato

MILK TYPE

Sheep - Raw

PRODUCTION

The base Manchego process is followed (see shepherds basket) with the addition of cracked white peppercorns right before the cooked curd is molded.

AFFINAGE

Five months minimum is what’s needed to allow the milk and rennet to reach the full flavor profile. The wheels are brushed regularly but the rind is allowed to mold naturally.

TASTING NOTES

At five months the cheese has an intense and mature flavor with distinctive buttery notes coupled with a full and fruity flavor. The cracked white peppercorns scattered throughout the cheese add a mild but distinct zing which blends rather then overwhelm the base sheep cheese flavors

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Safronella

MILK TYPE

Sheep - Raw

PRODUCTION

Fresh sheep milk is warmed and infused with saffron petals before production starts. Cheesemaking here is simple as with most sheep milk cheeses allowing the natural goodness of the milk to create the product. Green peppercorns are scattered throughout the curd before molding into five pound wheels.

AFFINAGE

Aged on Ash wood boards for three months while allowing natural molds to populate the rind while brushing down any overgrowth.

TASTING NOTES

The flavor ranges from mild to medium piquant, depending on how mature it is, and it has a characteristic aroma with light notes of saffron.

Mostly Summer / Fall

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Senora

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Gouda with Hot peppers and Jalapenos added to the curd during processing and before final molding. Made from full fat Jersey cow milk. Ten pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days minimum aging on Ash wood slabs in cave room at 50-54f.

TASTING NOTES

Semi-hard, with a stick to the roof of your mouth, smooth texture and containing a few holes. The hot peppers and sliced jalapenos inclusion adds the desired heat.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Shepherd Basket

MILK TYPE

Sheep - Raw

PRODUCTION

The Manchego name is synonymous with sheep milk and our version stays true to tradition. Using homemade lamb rennet enhances enzyme activity that adds flavor nuances to the final product. Basket molds are used to create the traditional cross hatch pattern.

AFFINAGE

Five months minimum is what’s needed to allow the milk and rennet to reach the full flavor profile. The wheels are brushed regularly but the rind is allowed to mold naturally.

TASTING NOTES

At five months the cheese has an intense and mature flavor with distinctive buttery notes coupled with a full and fruity flavor. The milk and rennet combine to create an apparent acidity which simulates a dry tone while also releasing a nutty, caramel taste.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Smokey Shepherd

MILK TYPE

Sheep - Raw

PRODUCTION

Smoked sheep milk cheeses dominate many cultures because they were created accidently and naturally while drying around the smoke filled production sheds. We use fully mature wheels and smoke with applewood for 8-10 hours.

AFFINAGE

Before smoking, ninety days on Ash boards is enough to free the flavors and aromas locked in fresh sheep’s milk.

TASTING NOTES

The rind turns brown and oily while the interior displays tones of caramel and nuttiness that only sheep cheese can achieve at three months.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Somerset

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional long age Alpine cheese. Thermophilic process requires very small curd cut and subsequent heating to 120 degrees F. The handmade screw press and teak wood boards help press these jumbo sized 40 pound wheels.

AFFINAGE

Eighteen Months aging on Ash wood slabs in cave room at 50-54f. Rind is washed irregularly with our morge.

TASTING NOTES

It is a semi-hard cheese, pale yellow in color, with a texture that is supple, grainy, firm, and crystalline. Its flavor is deep nutty, smokey, fruity and sweet.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Soprano

MILK TYPE

Sheep – Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Pecorino Romano production. Curd is cut very small with subsequent heating to over 120F. Wheels are molded at over 50 Lbs each and pressed for over a day. Salting takes place over 10-12 days.

AFFINAGE

Minimum 5 months and up to 18 months on Ash wood slabs in our cave at 50-54f and over 85% humidity.  The rind is rubbed with olive oil regularly to reduce mold growth and seal in moisture

TASTING NOTES

It is a hard cheese, pale yellow in color, with a texture that is supple, grainy, and crystalline after 8 months. Its flavor is deep nutty, smokey, fruity and sweet. As the only sheep milk Romano made in the US, our take is not a copy.  It is less salty, very approachable, granular, aromatic and just a joy to snack on.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Tartufo Shepherd

MILK TYPE

Sheep – Raw

PRODUCTION

The high protein levels in sheep milk require close attention and fast action. After the curd is cut and warmed up, additional staff waits for the bucket of black truffle shavings to be added before joining the crew to mold before the curds cool down. The 5 pound wheels are drained quickly and pressed for two hours.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days on Ash boards is enough time to free the flavors and aromas locked in fresh sheep’s milk and allow the truffle’s essence to permeate the wheel.

TASTING NOTES

Truffle dominates, with a purpose. It marries the mature sheep cheese texture creating a flavor combination for the ages.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Tewksbury

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional Alpine cheese. Thermophilic process requires very small curd cut and subsequent heating to 120 degrees F. Twenty pound wheel.

AFFINAGE

Twelve Months aging on Ash wood slabs in cave room at 50-54f. Rind is washed irregularly with our morge.

TASTING NOTES

It has a mild smell and an intensely fruity, buttery and hazelnut flavor, with the balance of acidity and sweetness, followed by a lingering aftertaste.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

TPK Blue

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

A dryer blue requires much hand work in the vat as the curds are turned over for ninety minutes and mixed with salt. When deemed ready, the curds are piled into large baskets and allowed to knit together overnite. The nine pound wheels are pierced and aged for ninety days.

AFFINAGE

Ninety days, thirty of which are spent open, bluing, and the balance wrapped in aluminum foil, maturing.

TASTING NOTES

A more approachable blue with a milder finish. A dryer version of our famous Crema cheese with a less spicy finish.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Valley Thunder

MILK TYPE

Jersey Cow - Raw

PRODUCTION

Traditional cloth bound cheddar. The slabs are hand stacked in a nine hour process that produces 22 pound truckles which are bound in their own linen cloth.

AFFINAGE

Twelve Month on Ash wood slabs.

TASTING NOTES

Our classic cloth bound cheddar is nutty and sweet, with a subtle tangy finish. The aging produces a pronounced sharpness that is balanced by the cheese’s creamy, melt-in-your-mouth texture.

Year Round

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY

NAME

Verigoat

MILK TYPE

Goat - Raw

PRODUCTION

A rather simple semi-hard, cooked curd goat cheese using home-made goat kid rennet. Raw goat milk is cultured, renneted and cut into small cubes which are then heated before the whey is removed and molding takes place. Bricks are about five pounds.

AFFINAGE

Simple aging on Ash wood slabs. Three to five month in our main hard cheese aging room. Growing molds are brushed off regularly.

TASTING NOTES

The simplicity, smooth texture and somewhat fruity mild goat taste has propelled Verigoat to our top 3 in five years.

Year Round Often Sold Out

CHECK FOR AVAILABILITY